Who ate all the pies? Proper Steak & Cheese Pie
$18.99
The Iconic Kiwi pie, taken to the next level. We use the finest Southland sirloin, diced by hand, seared and cooked low and slow in our very own rich beef stock. A generous helping of tasty cheese finishes off this tasty local favourite
114 reviews for Who ate all the pies? Proper Steak & Cheese Pie
Show all
Most Helpful
Highest Rating
Lowest Rating
GFK –
Pie was as good as expected.
Raza –
Pies are a “treat food” for me (occasional), so if I have one it has got to be good!
This ticked most of the boxes for me, tasty gravy with good chunks of actual meat, and the pastry was good.
It also held together really well (easy to eat on the move).
I was happy it was “light on cheese”, but get the comments that it was not very cheesy.
Paul Leadbetter –
A great wee pie. Tast gravy with generous large bits of meat. The pastry was very good. Somehow though the cheese was so slight you could not taste it.
Lorraine –
500% better than any other steak & cheese pie I’ve ever had. I’d give it 10 stars.
Geraldine –
Great pie!!! Very tasty filling and was a good option for a quick meal.
Rachel Merritt –
I loved this pie! I feel it is so much nicer than other brands. There is a generous portion of meat and filling, the gravy is so yummy & creamy & the pastry is perfect!
Michelle –
Delicious tasting pie, good filling to cheese ratio. Nice pastry!
Riaan –
Not a bad pie . I struggled to find the cheese though. In general good pie and it hit the spot when I ate it as a snack on my desk in the office. I have tasted better but hey I got it for free and it’s a boys pie so happy as Larry. Thanks
Kathleen –
Good pie – generous filling – the cheese was a little overpowering and the meat could have had more seasoning, but all in all a satisfying pie.
DS – Auckland –
Good pie, good filling tasty.
DS – Auckland –
Good pie, tasty and good filling
Debbie Lockart – Auckland –
Great filling, very nice meat. Pastry was a bit thick or my tastes but it didn’t stop me from eating all the Pie 🙂